Serving Mapleton, Illinois since 2022

Mapleton Mail

Innocent or Guilty, Do Her Words Make a Difference

Casey Anthony: Where the Truth Lies


Genre: Documentary, Crime
Year Released: 2022
Runtime: 3x 1h episodes
Showrunner/Director(s): Alexandra Haggiag Dean
Where To Watch: Premiering on Peacock November 29, 2022 Watch Here

RAVING REVIEW: Unless you’ve lived under a rock, you’ve likely heard of Casey Anthony, a well-known name, for all the wrong reasons. Is that fair, though? That’s what this three-part docuseries looks to shine some light on.

This was a complex series to watch, made even more difficult if you have any preconceived ideas about what Anthony was guilty of. In short, Anthony’s daughter Caylee went missing in 2008, and the story only gets more confusing and convoluted from that moment on. We’ll likely never know what happened to Caylee.

We know that Casey has had 11-plus years after being acquitted of murder to get her stories in line, and that’s what we hear in this series. I would genuinely be curious to hear from someone who didn’t know anything about this case and their opinion after watching this. For the same reason, I wouldn’t be on a jury for this case; it’s the same reason I had a hard time watching this with unbiased eyes.

To Casey’s credit, she has admitted her wrongdoing and the countless lies she told. From that point on, the story evolves and almost takes a life of its own. While I don’t know how I feel after watching this, I know that if the story being told has any hint of truth, there’s much more to uncover here.

When this trial took place in 2011, social media was blooming; the world had never seen anything like this. When O.J. Simpson went to trial, it was a different world; while televised, we have no clue how differently public opinion would’ve been had social media been around.

This is probably one of the most confusing situations that I’ve ever watched a documentary on. There are so many holes and unknown facts about the case, so many lies, and so many situations between Casey and her father that there’s no way of knowing what is and isn’t fact. Sadly Caylee paid the ultimate price, and in the end, her murderer is running free (whoever that is.)

For more reviews and my YouTube channel, please visit

Follow me on Instagram, Letterboxd, Twitter, and YouTube. Find my social media accounts on most platforms simply by searching Overly Honest Movie Reviews.

I’m always happy to hear from my readers; please say hi or send me any questions about all things movies.

Chris Jones
Entertainment Editor

Chris Jones is the Mail Entertainment Editor covering Movies and Television topics. He is from Washington, Illinois, and is the owner, writer, and editor of Overly Honest Reviews.