A New Realm Where Imperfection Rules

TV SERIES REVIEW
The Mighty Nein: Season 1
 -     

Genre: Animation, Fantasy, Adventure, Dramedy
Year Released: 2025
Runtime: 8 x 30m episodes
Cast: Laura Bailey, Liam O’Brien, Marisha Ray, Ashley Johnson, Travis Willingham, Sam Riegel, Taliesin Jaffe, Matthew Mercer, Ming-Na Wen, Mark Strong, Alan Cumming, Auli’i Cravalho, Anika Noni Rose, Ivanna Sakhno, Tim McGraw
Where to Watch: premiering on Prime Video November 19, 2025

RAVING REVIEW: THE MIGHTY NEIN marks the next step for Critical Role’s expanding universe. Following the success of THE LEGEND OF VOX MACHINA, this animated adaptation of the tabletop campaign dives headfirst into darker, stranger, and more emotionally complex territory. Where VOX MACHINA leaned on boisterous energy and humor, THE MIGHTY NEIN sharpens its focus on fractured characters and the messy “humanity” behind their heroics. The result is an eight-episode first season that balances adventure, absurdity, and anguish in equal measure.

The show begins with a group of outcasts who share little in common beyond their propensity for making poor decisions and a knack for creating chaos. Bound by secrets, scars, and the worst luck, the Nein are drawn together when a powerful relic known as The Beacon falls into the wrong hands. From there, the show builds a layered world of political deceit, shifting alliances, and emotional vulnerability, making this far more than just another animated fantasy. It’s a story about broken people learning to trust one another in a world that has given them every reason not to.

One of the show’s biggest triumphs is its ability to maintain a consistent tone. It walks a fine line between drama and crazy, never shying away from humor but refusing to treat the characters as jokes. Each episode finds ways to balance laughter, often within the same breath. A sarcastic quip is followed by a moment of heartbreak, and that dynamic keeps the series from feeling predictable.

The voice cast, drawn from Critical Role’s own roster of voice actors, remains this franchise’s greatest asset. Laura Bailey’s Jester is a chaotic delight, full of impish mischief and genuine warmth. Liam O’Brien gives Caleb a quiet, haunted dignity, allowing moments of brilliance to peek through his self-loathing. Marisha Ray’s Beauregard is fierce and flawed in ways that feel achingly human. The entire ensemble works in perfect rhythm, clearly informed by years of improvisational storytelling together. Guest stars like Ming-Na Wen, Mark Strong, and Alan Cumming add gravitas without overshadowing the core team.

Where THE MIGHTY NEIN differs from its predecessor is in its depth. The show isn’t afraid to dwell in uncertainty or pain. These are characters defined as much by regret as by heroism, and the writing gives them space to process their pasts rather than simply getting through them. That said, it never becomes self-serious. Humor still flows naturally from the chaos of the group dynamic, especially in moments when their plans collapse. The comedy isn’t written for easy laughs—it feels organic, born from the essence of who these characters are.

The pacing of the first season is tighter than expected for a sprawling fantasy ensemble. The show avoids long detours and instead builds momentum toward a clear central mystery: the nature and danger of The Beacon. While some side plots feel slightly rushed, the overall arc holds together impressively well, allowing each main character at least one spotlight moment that deepens their identity and contribution to the group. The season’s midpoint delivers an especially strong emotional pivot that reframes how the Nein view each other, setting the stage for future seasons with plenty of room to grow.

It’s also refreshing how the show resists the temptation to explain everything. Unlike many high-fantasy series that front-load lore, THE MIGHTY NEIN trusts its audience to catch up. You learn about this world through character choices, not exposition dumps. It’s a storytelling decision that rewards attention and mirrors the improvisational unpredictability of the tabletop source. Viewers unfamiliar with Critical Role won’t feel alienated; they’ll simply be dropped into a living world where understanding comes from experience rather than narration.

By the finale, what lingers isn’t just the spectacle or the world-building—it’s the intimacy. These characters, as flawed as they are, feel authentic. The show never lets you forget that heroism doesn’t always look noble. Sometimes it’s selfish, sometimes it’s clumsy, and sometimes it’s just about holding on when everything else is falling apart. That’s the heartbeat of THE MIGHTY NEIN, and it’s what makes this adaptation stand out in a crowded field of fantasy series.

THE MIGHTY NEIN: SEASON ONE succeeds because it remembers that fantasy isn’t just about power—it’s about people. It’s about how broken souls find belonging, how humor coexists with heartbreak, and how even in a world filled with magic, the hardest spell to master is trust. For Critical Role fans, it’s a worthy continuation of a legacy. For newcomers, it’s an invitation into a world of chaos, connection, and courage that’s worth accepting.

@LVMandM9onPrime
@Critical_Role
@criticalrole
#TheMightyNein

Please visit https://linktr.ee/overlyhonestr for more reviews.

You can follow me on Letterboxd, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube. My social media accounts can also be found on most platforms by searching for 'Overly Honest Reviews'.

I’m always happy to hear from my readers; please don't hesitate to say hello or send me any questions about movies.

[photo courtesy of PRIME VIDEO, AMAZON MGM STUDIOS, CRITICAL ROLE, TITMOUSE FOR PRIME VIDEO]

DISCLAIMER:
At Overly Honest Movie Reviews, we value honesty and transparency. Occasionally, we receive complimentary items for review, including DVDs, Blu-rays, CDs, Vinyl Records, Books, and more. We assure you that these arrangements do not influence our reviews, as we are committed to providing unbiased and sincere evaluations. We aim to help you make informed entertainment choices regardless of our relationship with distributors or producers.

Amazon Affiliate Links:
Additionally, this site contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This affiliate arrangement does not affect our commitment to honest reviews and helps support our site. We appreciate your trust and support in navigating these links.