When the Watchers Become the Watched

Read Time:5 Minute, 48 Second

TV SERIES REVIEW
Anne Rice's Talamasca: The Secret Order
–

Genre: Horror, Supernatural, Thriller
Year Released: 2025
Runtime: 6 episodes
Director(s): John Lee Hancock
Writer(s): Mark Lafferty, John Lee Hancock, Christopher Rice
Cast: Nicholas Denton, Elizabeth McGovern, William Fichtner, Maisie Richardson-Sellers, Celine Buckens, Jason Schwartzman, Eric Bogosian, Justin Kirk
Where to Watch: Two-Episode Series Premiere Sunday, October 26, 2025, on AMC and AMC+; New Episodes Weekly until the Season Finale on November 23

RAVING REVIEW: ANNE RICE’S TALAMASCA: THE SECRET ORDER shows up with an unusual mission: to expand Rice’s Immortal Universe beyond its familiar bloodlines and covens, into the minds of those who’ve spent centuries watching from the shadows. It’s part gothic mystery, part supernatural espionage thriller — and against all odds, it mostly works. This six-episode series finds a balance between character-driven tension and world-expanding spectacle, creating something that feels both familiar and new around every corner.

Nicholas Denton leads as Guy Anatole, a law student whose carefully planned future shatters the moment a secret organization appears at his door. The Talamasca — an order sworn to monitor and contain supernatural forces — has been tracking him since childhood. The reveal sends him spiraling into a world of haunted archives, blood-soaked diplomacy, and agents who can no longer tell where morality ends and survival begins. It’s a premise that feels like INTERVIEW WITH THE VAMPIRE collided with TINKER TAILOR SOLDIER SPY, and that combination gives the show its pulse.

John Lee Hancock, known for more grounded dramas like THE BLIND SIDE and THE FOUNDER, directs with restraint. He doesn’t chase constant action or cheap scares. Instead, he builds an atmosphere of menace — candlelit corridors, whispered codes, and a creeping sense that every ally has a secret agenda. The result is one of the most confidently paced shows in AMC’s Immortal Universe, avoiding the bloat that often comes with shared-universe storytelling.

What gives TALAMASCA its bite is the cast. Denton’s Guy carries the wide-eyed disbelief of someone thrust into a nightmare bureaucracy, but he evolves quickly. There’s a clear undercurrent of moral conflict as he begins to realize that the organization he’s joined may not be the savior it pretends to be. Elizabeth McGovern, as Helen, brings a commanding stillness to her role as the leader of the New York Motherhouse — a woman burdened by history yet unwilling to relinquish control. She’s not quite villainous, but her calm authority hints at a past filled with difficult choices and lingering guilt.

William Fichtner, as Jasper, becomes the show’s scene-stealer — mysterious, manipulative, and always three steps ahead. His presence in the London Motherhouse sets up a tension that ripples through the series. Meanwhile, Maisie Richardson-Sellers and Celine Buckens add texture and humanity to the supporting cast, grounding the story in something more emotionally tangible than mere lore. Jason Schwartzman’s guest role as Burton, a jaded vampire living in decadent isolation, injects welcome chaos into the mix. His sardonic charm and unpredictable alliances make him a perfect bridge between this series and Rice’s other creations.

Fans of INTERVIEW WITH THE VAMPIRE will appreciate the crossovers. Eric Bogosian returns as journalist Daniel Molloy, still obsessed with documenting the unseen, while Justin Kirk reprises his role as Raglan James, a Talamasca agent with secrets of his own. Their inclusion feels organic, enriching the continuity without overwhelming the narrative. For once, a shared-universe expansion remembers that intrigue is more powerful than exposition.

Each episode focuses on a distinct piece of the organization — from recruit initiation to covert field operations — but there’s an evolving mystery at its core: the legend of the “Seven Five Two,” an event or entity that could fracture the fragile balance between humans and immortals. The show’s best moments come when it leans into that uncertainty, blending moral ambiguity with supernatural danger. Hancock and Mark Lafferty understand that Rice’s world isn’t about jump scares or explosions; it’s about temptation, secrecy, and the fear of losing one’s humanity in the pursuit of understanding it.

At its best, ANNE RICE’S TALAMASCA: THE SECRET ORDER feels like the missing link between the existing Anne Rice adaptations. This entity ties the threads of vampires, witches, and mortals together under one ancient oath. It’s not content to merely exist within the franchise; it seeks to redefine its scope. The decision to tell a contained, six-episode story also works in its favor, avoiding the narrative sprawl that doomed other ambitious genre shows.

There’s also a distinct sense of tragedy throughout the performances. These are people who have devoted their lives to watching others — cursed to observe but never belong. Whether human or supernatural, every character carries the weight of isolation. By the finale, the show’s central question emerges: if the Talamasca exists to protect humanity from the supernatural, who protects humanity from the Talamasca? It’s a fittingly ominous note for a series that thrives on blurred lines. Hancock doesn’t offer easy answers — just the promise of deeper corruption and revelations to come.

AMC’s Immortal Universe needed a project like this — one that reclaims the mystery and elegance of Rice’s mythology while expanding its possibilities. ANNE RICE’S TALAMASCA: THE SECRET ORDER isn’t flawless, but it’s confident, atmospheric, and full of promise. It watches, indeed — and now, so will audiences. It’s smart, stylish, and layered — the rare expansion that feels earned rather than manufactured.

Please visit https://linktr.ee/overlyhonestr for more reviews.

You can follow me on Letterboxd, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube. My social media accounts can also be found on most platforms by searching for 'Overly Honest Reviews'.

I’m always happy to hear from my readers; please don't hesitate to say hello or send me any questions about movies.

[photo courtesy of AMC+, AMC]

DISCLAIMER:
At Overly Honest Movie Reviews, we value honesty and transparency. Occasionally, we receive complimentary items for review, including DVDs, Blu-rays, CDs, Vinyl Records, Books, and more. We assure you that these arrangements do not influence our reviews, as we are committed to providing unbiased and sincere evaluations. We aim to help you make informed entertainment choices regardless of our relationship with distributors or producers.

Amazon Affiliate Links:
Additionally, this site contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This affiliate arrangement does not affect our commitment to honest reviews and helps support our site. We appreciate your trust and support in navigating these links.