When Small Towns Hide the Darkest Things

Read Time:5 Minute, 25 Second

MOVIE REVIEW
Dead Mail
–

Genre: Crime, Drama, Horror, Thriller
Year Released: 2024, 2025
Runtime: 1h 46m
Director(s): Joe DeBoer, Kyle McConaghy
Writer(s): Joe DeBoer, Kyle McConaghy
Cast: Sterling Macer Jr., John Fleck, Susan Priver, Micki Jackson, Tomas Boykin, Nick Heyman, Sean Heyman, Aaron Phifer, Michael Cambridge, Micah Fitzgerald, Sharieff Walters
Where to Watch: Available streaming on Shudder on April 18, 2025

RAVING REVIEW: Something is fascinating about watching a film that feels like it was unearthed from another time but with just enough weirdness to make it stick in your brain. That’s the strange magic: nostalgia meets innovation, and everything is filtered through the grainy, analog lens of a dreamlike version of Peoria, Illinois. Even though it wasn’t shot there, it’s rooted in the city’s energy, which made it hit even closer to home for me—seeing Peoria get this kind of spotlight. I’ll take it.

Rather than opting for a straightforward mystery or horror blueprint, DEAD MAIL zigs when most movies zag. It opens with a moment of tension—a bound and bruised man scraping together just enough strength to mail out a bloodstained cry for help. That fragment of panic sets off an unlikely investigation, one that lands on the desk of Jasper, a postal sleuth whose job is tracking down the senders of undeliverable mail. That might not sound like the premise of a gripping thriller, but in this case, it becomes the springboard into a world where obsession, technology, and fractured human connection collide.

As Jasper follows the breadcrumbs left by the note, he finds himself entangled with Trent, a character who shifts between charming and chilling with unnerving ease. Trent’s link to Josh—a soft-spoken synth engineer—is where things get unhinged. Together, they represent two sides of the same coin: one fueled by the pursuit of artistic perfection, the other by control. Their partnership has an eerie symmetry; watching it unravel is part of the film’s draw.

This is not a movie that holds your hand. Its structure is intentionally jarring, jumping between timelines and characters with minimal exposition. But instead of feeling disjointed, it builds a sense of dread and curiosity. The narrative fragments slowly connect, revealing more through tone and behavior than dialogue. That choice will likely frustrate viewers expecting a clean three-act structure, but it adds to the allure for those willing to play detective alongside the characters.

Aesthetically, DEAD MAIL leans hard into its 80s inspiration—but not in the overly stylized way that’s become trendy lately. Instead, the visual choices lean grittier, with faded colors and textures that mimic an aging VHS tape. The production team put effort into creating something immersive rather than gimmicky. The analog tech, the muted wardrobe, and even the cluttered workspaces all contribute to an atmosphere grounded in a specific time and mood.

The cast is dialed into that world, too. Tomas Boykin, as Jasper, offers a steady center amid the madness. He brings a methodical intensity to a role that could easily be played for laughs. John Fleck’s take on Trent is arguably the most memorable part of the film—his stillness and delivery make every moment feel unpredictable. Sterling Macer Jr., as Josh, gives one of the quieter performances, but that restraint works in his favor. His character’s journey is less about dialogue and more about what’s simmering beneath the surface.

Sound is used brilliantly throughout—not just the score, though that’s certainly a standout, but the overall sound design—how static creeps into moments of tension, how ambient noise builds unease. The music isn’t just a background element; it reflects character moods and motivations. It’s an emotional language, and the film understands how to wield it without overwhelming the story.

Another detail worth noting is how the film handles character dynamics, especially between the women and the central narrative. Too often, genre stories sideline their female characters, but here, Ann and Bess—two postal employees—play a key role in piecing together the mystery. They’re not caricatures or background noise; they actively drive the plot forward. Their curiosity and courage stand in contrast to the more obsessive tendencies of the men, creating a subtle but effective thematic counterweight.

At its heart, DEAD MAIL isn’t about the crime itself—it’s about the people affected by it and how obsession manifests in different ways. Whether it’s a fixation on solving puzzles, achieving perfection, or simply being remembered, every character is reaching for something that constantly feels out of grasp. And the film makes its most resonant points in those quieter moments—the longing, the silence, the confusion.

The result is a weird, thoughtful project that is full of personality. It won’t work for every viewer, and that’s part of its charm. DEAD MAIL has a specific core audience and tone that won’t please everyone, but it’s a uniquely satisfying experience for those tuned in. More than just a retro mystery, it’s a story about control, connection, and how far people will go to be heard—even if it means trusting the mail to carry your last desperate words.

Please visit https://linktr.ee/overlyhonestr for more reviews.

You can follow me on Letterboxd, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube. My social media accounts can also be found on most platforms by searching Overly Honest Reviews.

I’m always happy to hear from my readers; please say hi or send me any questions about movies.

[photo courtesy of SHUDDER]

DISCLAIMER:
At Overly Honest Movie Reviews, we value honesty and transparency. Occasionally, we receive free items for review, including DVDs, Blu-rays, CDs, Vinyl, Books, etc. We assure you that these arrangements do not influence our reviews, as we are committed to providing unbiased and sincere evaluations. We aim to help you make informed entertainment choices regardless of our relationship with distributors or producers.

Amazon Affiliate Links:
Additionally, this site contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This affiliate arrangement does not affect our commitment to honest reviews and helps support our site. We appreciate your trust and support in navigating these links.