A Legal Thriller Rooted in Real-World Trauma and Resilience

Read Time:5 Minute, 16 Second

TV SERIES REVIEW
The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox
–

Genre: True-Crime Drama, Limited Series
Year Released: 2025
Format: 8 x 55m episodes
Creator/Showrunner: K.J. Steinberg
Directors: Michael Uppendahl, Cate Shortland, Natalie Leite, Quyen Tran
Cast: Grace Van Patten, Sharon Horgan, John Hoogenakker, Francesco Acquaroli, Giuseppe De Domenico, Roberta Mattei
Where to Watch: premieres August 20, 2025, with two episodes. New episodes stream weekly on Wednesdays

RAVING REVIEW: THE TWISTED TALE OF AMANDA KNOX makes it clear from the first episode that it isn’t interested in rehashing myths. Instead, it offers a deliberate and layered examination of a case that consumed headlines for years, reframing Amanda Knox not as the villain many were told she was, but as a young woman caught in the perfect storm of overreach, media sensationalism, and public bias.

The series avoids becoming a standard true-crime mystery. Showrunner K.J. Steinberg shapes it as a “how” and “why” rather than a “who,” shifting the focus to the mechanisms that allowed a wrongful conviction to happen. From investigative tunnel vision to the global appetite for scandal, each episode lays out how the narrative spiraled into something detached from reality.

Grace Van Patten leads the series with a performance that captures Knox’s early optimism, growing disorientation, and eventual resolve. Her portrayal is nuanced—never leaning into caricature or oversimplification. Sharon Horgan, as Knox’s mother Edda Mellas, conveys a deep well of resilience, while John Hoogenakker, as Curt Knox, anchors the family’s perspective with quiet strength. Giuseppe De Domenico’s Raffaele Sollecito is both charming and vulnerable. Francesco Acquaroli’s portrayal of Prosecutor Giuliano Mignini avoids making him a one-note antagonist, instead presenting him as a man convinced of a flawed version of the truth.

Each episode rotates perspectives, sometimes giving entire hours over to figures other than Knox. This approach broadens the lens, encouraging viewers to question why Knox’s name endures in public memory while others involved in the case remain obscure. It also humanizes the others in ways that resist the tidy hero-villain dichotomy so often found in dramatizations of true events.

Visually, the series captures both the charm and the claustrophobia of Perugia (an Italian city and the capital of the Umbria region). Bright, picturesque streets contrast with the oppressive interiors of police stations and courtrooms. In select moments, the tone shifts toward the whimsical—a nod to Knox’s favorite film, AMÉLIE—used sparingly to represent the world as she saw it before her arrest. These brief flourishes never undercut the gravity of the story; instead, they offer a glimpse into the personality and worldview Knox struggled to hold onto amid chaos.

The writing balances empathy with scrutiny. Knox is not portrayed as infallible—her missteps are acknowledged—but the series contextualizes them against the disproportionate weight of the accusations and the ease with which her image was distorted. The media circus is depicted as a force of destruction, shaping public opinion long before facts could intervene.

Importantly, the story continues beyond Knox’s acquittal. By showing her struggle to rebuild a life in a world still eager to doubt her, the series underscores that wrongful convictions don’t end with a verdict. The final episodes focus on her attempt to confront the man who once prosecuted her, illustrating a level of personal reckoning that goes beyond clearing her name.

The tone throughout shifts between tense courtroom drama, procedural moments, and personal introspection. There are absurd moments drawn from the real circus surrounding the case, but they’re tempered by the central tragedy: Meredith Kercher’s death and the ripple effects of the rush to judgment. The series treats that loss with respect, ensuring Kercher isn’t reduced to a mere plot device.

While the pacing holds attention across all eight episodes, a few sequences lean heavily on stylistic choices that could divide viewers, particularly the whimsical interludes. They work as a thematic device but may feel at odds with the otherwise grounded presentation for some audiences. Even so, they’re brief enough not to derail the momentum, and I think they’re a welcome addition. I can just see where they may rub some the wrong way.

THE TWISTED TALE OF AMANDA KNOX succeeds because it doesn’t attempt to be the definitive account of the case. Instead, it’s an exploration of perception, memory, and the cost of a story told too soon by too many. It reframes one of the most talked-about legal sagas of the 21st century as a cautionary tale about the fragility of truth when institutions and public opinion converge against it. For those who think they know the Amanda Knox story, this series offers something more valuable than a re-litigation of facts—it provides a human perspective on how quickly anyone can become the face of a story they didn’t write.

Please visit https://linktr.ee/overlyhonestr for more reviews.

You can follow me on Letterboxd, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube. My social media accounts can also be found on most platforms by searching for 'Overly Honest Reviews'.

I’m always happy to hear from my readers; please don't hesitate to say hello or send me any questions about movies.

[photo courtesy of HULU, DISNEY+, KNOX ROBINSON PRODUCTIONS, 20TH CENTURY FOX TELEVISION, 20TH TELEVISION, ALT ENDING PRODUCTIONS, GOOD TALK., THE LITTLEFIELD COMPANY]

DISCLAIMER:
At Overly Honest Movie Reviews, we value honesty and transparency. Occasionally, we receive complimentary items for review, including DVDs, Blu-rays, CDs, Vinyl Records, Books, and more. We assure you that these arrangements do not influence our reviews, as we are committed to providing unbiased and sincere evaluations. We aim to help you make informed entertainment choices regardless of our relationship with distributors or producers.

Amazon Affiliate Links:
Additionally, this site contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This affiliate arrangement does not affect our commitment to honest reviews and helps support our site. We appreciate your trust and support in navigating these links.