A Hollywood Whodunit Wanders

Read Time:6 Minute, 24 Second

MOVIE REVIEW
Sunset (Retro VHS Packaging)
–

Genre: Comedy, Mystery, Western, Crime
Year Released: 1988, 2026 Mill Creek Blu-ray
Runtime: 1h 42m
Director(s): Blake Edwards
Writer(s): Rod Amateau, Blake Edwards
Cast: Bruce Willis, James Garner, Malcolm McDowell, Mariel Hemingway, Kathleen Quinlan, Jennifer Edwards, Patricia Hodge, M. Emmet Walsh
Where to Watch: available June 23, 2026, pre-order your copy here: www.moviesunlimited.com or www.amazon.com

RAVING REVIEW: SUNSET has a premise that sounds like it should be impossible to fumble. Wyatt Earp, living out his final days in old Hollywood, works as a technical adviser. At the same time, silent-era cowboy star Tom Mix plays him on screen, and the two men end up pulled into a murder mystery involving studio corruption, movie glamour, and dangerous secrets. That setup is so powerful that the movie earns a certain amount of patience just by putting James Garner and Bruce Willis in the same frame. The strange part is that SUNSET is often most enjoyable before it becomes too invested in the murder it wants them to solve. The idea is stronger than the plot, the leads are more interesting than the case, and the Hollywood setting has more personality than the script can organize.

Director/co-writer Blake Edwards approaches the film as a mix of period comedy, mystery, western, buddy flick, and old-Hollywood fantasy. That blend gives SUNSET an odd charm, but it also explains why the movie never settles into one shape. There’s a relaxed pleasure in watching the film play with the gap between Hollywood legends and lived experience, even when that gets interrupted by a whodunit that feels less compelling.

James Garner’s version of Wyatt Earp gives SUNSET most of the impact that makes it work. Garner doesn’t play Earp as a dusty relic brought in as a novelty. He gives him an arid intelligence, a steady gaze, and an awareness that the world has already turned him into a story, whether he asked for it or not. There’s humor in the performance, but it’s never empty. Garner understands that Earp’s power comes from how little he has to prove. He can underplay a threat, land a line without squeezing it, and make the character’s age feel like history rather than weakness. Garner gives the audience someone worth following.

Bruce Willis, still in the stretch where Hollywood was testing what kind of movie star he might become, brings a lighter charge as Tom Mix. He’s cocky, playful, and more relaxed than the script itself, which helps his scenes with Garner breathe. The pairing works because the movie doesn’t force a tired mentor-student conflict onto them. Tom Mix may be a movie cowboy, but he isn’t treated as a fraud. Earp may be the real thing, but he isn’t written as a joyless older man resentful of Hollywood. Their friendship develops quickly, maybe too quickly, but Garner and Willis sell the curiosity.

The film is also strongest when it lets the 1920s Hollywood setting become more than decoration. The silent-to-sound transition, the studio backlots, the staged western imagery, the nightlife, the costumes, and the idea of an industry already rewriting history as entertainment all give the movie a satisfying surface. SUNSET understands that old Hollywood wasn’t innocent, and the film has fun poking at the pieces of the puzzle behind the glamour. The film hints at exploitation, image control, blackmail, sexual hypocrisy, and studio power, but those ideas are mostly decoration for the larger film.

Malcolm McDowell’s Alfie Alperin is a fairly generic villain, a studio figure with a sinister public image and rot underneath, and McDowell certainly knows how to project cruelty. Jennifer Edwards, Patricia Hodge, Kathleen Quinlan, Mariel Hemingway, Richard Bradford, M. Emmet Walsh, and Joe Dallesandro all contribute to the period mystery. However, the film doesn’t always give them the room needed.

The murder plot is busy without being gripping. The film keeps adding complexities, more shady figures, personal connections, and dangerous encounters, but the mystery doesn’t tighten around the audience. It’s not hard to enjoy the ride in individual scenes, especially when Garner and Willis are trading reactions or moving through some corner of Hollywood, but the case itself rarely creates urgency. SUNSET feels like it should be more fun than it is, since the ingredients are all right there.

The historical playfulness helps. SUNSET isn’t pretending to be a factual account, and its own attitude toward truth is baked into its famous wink about how things “really” happened. That permits Edwards to turn Earp and Mix into mythic figures wandering through a fabricated Hollywood crime story. The film’s best idea is that both men are caught between reality and performance. Earp has become a legend while still alive, and Mix has built a career out of performing frontier courage that audiences want to believe in.

SUNSET makes sense in a release like this because it’s exactly the kind of studio-era oddity that benefits from rediscovery. It isn’t a buried classic, but it’s a curious, good-looking, star-driven film with a premise strange enough to keep it alive. The Retro VHS packaging angle fits because SUNSET feels tied to an era when browsing a shelf could lead someone to a movie simply because the cast and concept were too unusual to ignore. For collectors, that may be enough of a hook, especially for anyone interested in Bruce Willis before DIE HARD reshaped his screen identity or James Garner returning to western iconography with effortless command.

SUNSET lands with enough charm. The premise is terrific, Garner is excellent, Willis fits the role better than expected, and the old-Hollywood atmosphere gives the movie a welcome glow. The mystery, unfortunately, doesn’t always match the setup, and the film spends too much time wandering between tones instead of turning its best ideas into sharper entertainment. It’s enjoyable, uneven, and easy to like even while recognizing how much better it could have been. The movie may insist that it’s all true, give or take a lie or two, but the better truth is simpler. SUNSET works whenever it lets Garner and Willis enjoy the myth. It stumbles whenever it asks the murder plot to carry the whole picture.

Please visit https://linktr.ee/overlyhonestr for more reviews.

You can follow me on Letterboxd, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube. My social media accounts can also be found on most platforms by searching for 'Overly Honest Reviews'.

I’m always happy to hear from my readers; please don't hesitate to say hello or send me any questions about movies.

[photo courtesy of MOVIES UNLIMITED, MILL CREEK]

DISCLAIMER:
At Overly Honest Movie Reviews, we value honesty and transparency. Occasionally, we receive complimentary items for review, including DVDs, Blu-rays, CDs, Vinyl Records, Books, and more. We assure you that these arrangements do not influence our reviews, as we are committed to providing unbiased and sincere evaluations. We aim to help you make informed entertainment choices regardless of our relationship with distributors or producers.

Amazon Affiliate Links:
Additionally, this site contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This affiliate arrangement does not affect our commitment to honest reviews and helps support our site. We appreciate your trust and support as you navigate these links.