A Monster Movie Gets Too Real
MOVIE REVIEW
Minions & Monsters
–
Genre: Animation, Comedy, Adventure, Family
Year Released: 2026
Runtime: 1h 30m
Director: Pierre Coffin, Patrick Delage
Writers: Brian Lynch, Pierre Coffin
Cast: Pierre Coffin, Trey Parker, Allison Janney, Christoph Waltz, Jesse Eisenberg, Jeff Bridges, Zoey Deutch, Bobby Moynihan, Phil LaMarr
Where to Watch: available now; order your copy here: www.amazon.com
RAVING REVIEW: MINIONS & MONSTERS makes a fuss about the sound of a projector before it jokes about the arrival of sound in movies. The opening gives the machinery a chance to whir and rattle, and the projected images come with little ticks and pops. There’s a physical pleasure to the way those old pictures get started. It puts some actual equipment in a movie that could’ve gotten by on hats and the occasional reference to Charlie Chaplin. By the time the Minions wind up in a picture of their own, the camera is already something to be curious about. Somebody has to figure out how to get an image out of the thing.
The Minions’ first contribution to Hollywood comes from mistaking an actor for the sort of villain they’ve spent their lives looking to serve. James and his friends wander onto a set because they don’t know there’s a set to wander onto. Pierre Coffin and co-director Patrick Delage get some of their best comedy from the gap between what the crew is trying to film and what the Minions think they’ve walked into. A chase can send them into a Harold Lloyd gag and past a collapsing house that calls back to Buster Keaton. The important thing is that the action keeps moving through those references. A kid can follow who’s chasing whom and get the joke when the building comes down. Knowing where the stunt came from gives you something extra to enjoy the next time the movie sends somebody running.
Their accident happens at the right time to make them stars. Silent movies can do a lot with bodies that advertise exactly what they’re about to do, then do something messier. The Minions already know how to get an audience to follow a look or a scramble across a room. The talkies turn those same stars into a problem a studio can’t solve with another take. The business end of that joke is pretty good, too. Audiences can spend years enjoying somebody’s work, and the people paying for it can decide, almost overnight, that the very same act has become unusable. The filmmakers get to make that point with Minionese, which makes a reasonable amount of sense until somebody needs the Minions to deliver the lines on the page.
Ed gets a more interesting place in that story than he would in a version where every Minion communicated the same way. He’s deaf and signs in Minionese, which Coffin developed with a sign language coach. The film has already taught us to get information from an expression, a gesture, or what somebody’s doing with a prop. Ed’s signing belongs in that visual language and gives him a way of getting a thought across that’s his own. His presence also makes the shift to sound a little stranger. The studio can insist on recording spoken dialogue in every scene. From the other side of the screen, the audience has already learned how to follow him.
James and Henry make more sense as friends than they would as two equally committed young directors. James is the one who’s always making something. A pen in his hand tells you what he’s likely to do with a minute to himself, and Coffin can get that across before any of the other characters need to know what he’s planning. Henry spends enough time helping James that there’s something to lose when the movie starts taking up more of James’s attention than the people helping him make it. The script by Coffin and Brian Lynch understands how an idea can take hold of someone who’s used to having a friend nearby when the plan gets him in trouble. That gives them a disagreement that can survive a few jokes at their expense.
Christoph Waltz voices Max, the director the Minions befriend. His place in the story gives James somebody whose work he can get close enough to learn from. James has already seen that a person can become a movie star just by ending up in the right piece of footage, and making one of his own means thinking about what goes into the frame and why. The performance fits this part of the film because Max treats making movies as a job worth taking seriously, even when the people interested in learning it can barely get through a workday without breaking something. Enthusiasm comes easily to James. Seeing him around somebody who does this for a living makes his ambition a little easier to picture.
John Powell’s score also gets space to make the period feel like more than a production design choice. The music knows how much of the chase it can carry when there’s very little speech to do that work. Jeremy Bowker and Daniel Laurie worked with Powell so the sound effects could support the music, and the balance makes sense for a film where part of the fun is picking out what one small thing is doing amid a lot of activity. A thunder effect borrowed from the 1930s FRANKENSTEIN films lets the sound team carry some of that period detail into the monster material. It gives a new creature a connection to the kind of movie James has in mind through a noise you might remember even if you couldn’t name where you heard it.
The spellbook comes from a former boss, and it gives James what no sensible producer would let him put in the budget. Wanting to cast an actual monster in a monster movie is exactly the sort of shortcut that fits a Minion who’s thought harder about what ought to be on screen than what it’ll take to keep his set intact. The creatures do give him something new to work with. Jesse Eisenberg’s Dort talks up his credentials as a conqueror even though his living arrangements are comically modest. Eisenberg’s voice does most of the conquering. It makes sense in a film that’s already spent time on people making a living by putting across a version of themselves they might struggle to maintain off the lot.
The trouble comes when the monsters move from a production problem to a threat on a much bigger scale. The jokes on the lot can grow out of who’s supposed to be in charge of a shot and what happens when somebody takes that job too seriously. Once there’s a city to save, the film has less time for the decisions that made James’s production something only he and his friends would’ve attempted. The danger gives Henry and Ed reasons to act, and it keeps the movie moving. Some of the individual creatures are more fun to meet than they are to keep track of when the movie brings them together.
Hollywood has room in it for both versions of the movie. The studio that turns a few seconds of somebody’s accident into a career can also make a monster into a job for a whole crew. MINIONS & MONSTERS is best when one of those jobs stays in view long enough for the wrong person to try it. That’s what makes James worth following even when the mess he’s created gets bigger than the movie he meant to make. An accidental star can leave a set with no idea how he ended up in the picture. James wants to know where the camera was and what he’d have to do to put it somewhere else.
MINIONS TAKE ON HOLLYWOOD covers the decisions that went into recreating the period, and HOLLYWOOD SOUND gives Powell’s score a featurette of its own. There’s also a voice cast featurette and a set of drawing lessons with head of story Nima Azarba. The flipbook tutorial is particularly well matched to the movie. It gives kids a pencil-and-paper way to try the idea that got James so interested in filmmaking in the first place. There’s a separate slime tutorial for anyone more interested in making an Irene of their own.
Please visit https://linktr.ee/overlyhonestr for more reviews.
Follow me on Letterboxd, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube. You can also find my social media accounts on most platforms by searching for 'Overly Honest Reviews'.
I’m always happy to hear from my readers; please don't hesitate to say hello or send me any movie questions.
[photo courtesy of ILLUMINATION ENTERTAINMENT, UNIVERSAL PICTURES, DENTSU, FUJI TELEVISION NETWORK]
DISCLAIMER:
At Overly Honest Movie Reviews, we value honesty and transparency. Occasionally, we receive complimentary items for review, including DVDs, Blu-rays, CDs, Vinyl Records, Books, and more. We assure you these arrangements do not influence our reviews, as we are committed to unbiased, sincere evaluations. We aim to help you make informed entertainment choices regardless of our relationship with distributors or producers.
Amazon Affiliate Links:
This site also contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This affiliate arrangement does not affect our commitment to honest reviews and helps support our site. We appreciate your trust and support as you navigate these links.
Average Rating