The Long Way Out of Texas
MOVIE REVIEW
Carolina Caroline
–
Genre: Crime, Romance, Thriller
Year Released: 2025, 2026
Runtime: 1h 45m
Director(s): Adam Carter Rehmeier
Writer(s): Tom Dean
Cast: Samara Weaving, Kyle Gallner, Kyra Sedgwick, Jon Gries
Where to Watch: available now; order your copy here: www.amazon.com
RAVING REVIEW: Caroline Daniels meets Oliver at work, where he takes a few dollars off the man behind the register. There's practically nobody in the place. Oliver doesn't have to compete with a line of customers or raise his voice. He makes a crooked transaction look enough like an ordinary one for Charlie to go along with it. Caroline watches from nearby. She's used to being the one who gets customers their change and sends them on their way. Adam Carter Rehmeier makes better use of those few dollars than he does of some of the bigger sums later in CAROLINA CAROLINE. You learn a fair amount about Oliver from the way he takes them, and even more about Caroline from the fact that she wants to know how he did it.
In Texas, Caroline's time is split between the filling station and looking after her father, Hank. Weaving plays the attraction to Oliver against the obligations Caroline knows will be waiting for her when she comes home. Oliver can come and go without having to clear his plans with anybody. Caroline has to think about what will happen at home if she goes anywhere for longer than a shift. The time spent in Texas gives her something specific to leave behind. Hank will have to go on living there, and what looks like freedom to her will look different to him.
Gallner plays Oliver as somebody who can carry on a conversation without giving away exactly when he started working. Later, at a busy bar, the conditions for a short-change hustle are different. At the station, he has time to size up one person. At the bar, there's already plenty going on and one more request is easy to take in stride. Gallner's delivery fits a man who can make himself seem like part of either room. That ease matters once he's alone with Caroline. His attention can make Caroline feel like the only person in a room. The film gives you good reason to wonder what he does when that stops getting him what he wants.
The early cons are a good way to let two actors get comfortable with each other in front of us. Teaching Caroline gives Oliver something to do besides tell her she's special. He has to show her how he thinks, then give her space to try it. Weaving makes that education look like fun. Once Caroline can take part, Gallner has a partner who can change the direction of a scene, and Oliver has to keep up with the person he's been encouraging. Rehmeier had already directed Gallner in DINNER IN AMERICA. Here he puts that knack Gallner has for making somebody's company appealing to work in a romance where being happy to see the guy walk through the door is a perfectly good way to get yourself into trouble.
The move from short cons to bank jobs makes that rapport less important to the mechanics of the crime. An encounter with a cashier can turn on how long a person is willing to entertain a stranger. Introducing a gun narrows the range of responses considerably. The film understands how frightening that can be for someone on the other side of a counter, and a robbery gives Rehmeier room to move the story along quickly. Once the crimes start dictating where the couple can go, there's less time for Caroline and Oliver to reckon with how differently they can read the same situation. The script is good at showing Caroline pick up Oliver's habits. It rushes some of the decisions about which ones she'll keep.
It helps that Caroline has a destination of her own. She wants to find Deborah, the mother she grew up without, and that's a reason for a trip she'd have some use for even if it hadn't turned into a romance. Hank, played by Jon Gries, has done the ordinary work of raising her. Caroline's had years to picture Deborah without hearing her mother's side of the story. Tom Dean's script leaves room for Caroline to care about her father and to want something he can't give her. The trip to South Carolina has an emotional risk that doesn't depend on a bank teller reaching for an alarm. Caroline can get all the way there and have no say in what kind of conversation she's going to get.
Kyra Sedgwick's Deborah has the advantage of walking into a story in which we've spent a long time with the person looking for her. Sedgwick gets to speak for an adult with her own account of the past, and Weaving has to listen without the luxury of knowing how much of it she wants to hear. Rehmeier shot the film as close to story order as he could, and Weaving has said she barely knew Sedgwick when they played that scene. The production choice suits a meeting that depends on one person encountering a stranger with a familiar name. It's also a scene that puts Weaving's earlier work to good use. By this point Caroline has learned what to watch for when she needs to steer a conversation. That skill can only take her so far with somebody who's had her own reasons for staying away.
The places Caroline and Oliver can afford change as their work pays off. Rehmeier uses the ornate rooms of Louisville's Brown Hotel for some of their time together and a roadside motel with red doors elsewhere on the road. The hotel gives the pair a taste of how they'd like to spend an evening if money were easy to come by. The room is theirs for as long as they've paid for it, which is about as far ahead as their arrangement lets them plan. The period helps, too. The movie is set around the turn of the millennium, when making a call could mean stopping at a pay phone and a television could be where you found out what the police knew. Those stops give the trip a sense of geography and put public life right up against a couple who'd prefer to make their plans in private.
Editor Justin Krohn did much of the work of finding the country songs Rehmeier uses. There's a difference between the young Loretta Lynn singing “I'm a Honky Tonk Girl” and the years of hard living Jason Isbell brings to “Cover Me Up.” Putting both in the same movie gives it more than one way to talk about people trying to keep one another around. The older recordings also make sense in a movie where the cars and the phones provide firmer clues to the era than the music does. Rehmeier and cinematographer Jean-Philippe Bernier also give the music something specific to play against. They shoot two dances with the camera circling the couple in opposite directions. The resemblance lets you recognize the private pleasure these two take in each other's company, even as the circumstances around the second dance give it a different feeling.
Weaving keeps sight of somebody who was already doing the math on her life before a man with a car offered her a ride. That gives CAROLINA CAROLINE more to work with than the rush of getting away with something. Oliver can teach her how to walk into a room and come out with enough cash to get to the next town. The reason she wants to get there belongs to Caroline, and Weaving gives it a hold on her that a good night with Oliver can't shake.
Please visit https://linktr.ee/overlyhonestr for more reviews.
Follow me on Letterboxd, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube. You can also find my social media accounts on most platforms by searching for 'Overly Honest Reviews'.
I’m always happy to hear from my readers; please don't hesitate to say hello or send me any movie questions.
[photo courtesy of MAGNOLIA HOME ENTERTAINMENT, BEE-HIVE PRODUCTIONS, CREATE & COMPLETE ENTERTAINMENT, FILMNATION ENTERTAINMENT, MACPAC ENTERTAINMENT, STAR THROWER ENTERTAINMENT, THE WONDER COMPANY]
DISCLAIMER:
At Overly Honest Movie Reviews, we value honesty and transparency. Occasionally, we receive complimentary items for review, including DVDs, Blu-rays, CDs, Vinyl Records, Books, and more. We assure you these arrangements do not influence our reviews, as we are committed to unbiased, sincere evaluations. We aim to help you make informed entertainment choices regardless of our relationship with distributors or producers.
Amazon Affiliate Links:
This site also contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may receive a commission. This affiliate arrangement does not affect our commitment to honest reviews and helps support our site. We appreciate your trust and support as you navigate these links.
Average Rating